A Discriminative Approach to Predicting Assessor Accuracy

Modeling changes in individual relevance assessor performance over time offers new ways to improve the quality of relevance judgments, such as by dynamically routing judging tasks to assessors more likely to produce reliable judgments. Whereas prior assessor models have typically adopted a single generative approach, we formulate a discriminative, flexible feature-based model. This allows us to combine multiple generative models and integrate additional behavioral evidence, enabling better adaptation to temporal variance in assessor accuracy. Experiments using crowd assessor data from the NIST TREC 2011 Crowdsourcing Track show our model improves prediction accuracy by 26-36% across assessors, enabling 29-47% improved quality of relevance judgments to be collected at 17-45% lower cost.